WATPI Prep
Workshops
CAT' 23 Analysis
RTI Response
Selection Criteria 2023
Rankings
Best 50
Placements
Score Vs. %ile
Salaries

A 20 Lakh Job After B-School With 3 Months Of Effort - Do B-School Grades Matter?

Comments
 

K D

Policy Analyst

Does the dream FMCG company know that Nayan has learnt absolutely nothing in the 2 years he has spent in B-school and whose best skill is to bullshit his way through life?

14 Aug 2017, 06.36 PM

+Read Replies (5)

InsideIIM Counselling

Admin

The company probably trusts its own training over what professors at IIM Teach. Also, most companies look for aptitude and what really matters to them is whether they have cleared the CAT well and were decent enough to get an admit. Post that, the truth is that many companies don't care about whether the person does well academically at B-School.

14 Aug 2017, 06.43 PM |

InsideIIM Counselling

Admin

We would also point out the academic inflation in the employment market. Most jobs offered at B-Schools can be done by those who have an undergrad degree. However, the quality of undergrad degrees is so bad that everyone has to go to B-School to be employable. Not sure if B-School does that but it definitely ensures that there is a rigorous filtering criteria which makes the job of hiring for a lot of companies very easy. Then the company trainings and management trainee programmes, internships, rotations etc. which take over.

14 Aug 2017, 06.45 PM |

K D

Policy Analyst

So if I understand correctly, the rich literature of management education, taken from economics, finance, psychology, sociology, ethics etc., is of so little use in the complex and varied roles in industry and solving Class 10 math sums and basic comprehension so rigorous an indicator of 'aptitude', that all fresh entrants need to do is go through some internship primers, keep their head above water and talk shop during interviews, not to mention be sharp about fetching coffees during the summer internship?

14 Aug 2017, 07.21 PM |

InsideIIM Counselling

Admin

The truth lies somewhere in the middle. Driven management students will do the work expected of them but in the industry the companies rely on on their own training. Sad but true. Barring a few good business schools, a lot of tier-2 schools (and maybe even a few tier-1 schools) have very little of the 'riches' to offer.

14 Aug 2017, 07.44 PM |

K D

Policy Analyst

The only thing sad here is the lack of integrity being peddled as realism here. The rest, about what the industry wants and what the various tiers of b-schools have to offer is just lazy conjecture. A stark reminder on the eve of our Independence Day that corruption starts at the top.

15 Aug 2017, 08.12 AM |

Manojit Basak

Nayan is THE perfect example of what an mba graduate should be. He did manage both his time and efforts efficiently as well as effectively. Theoritical knowledge can be gained at any stage in life but managing the work in hand with this efficiency needs to be learnt from these particular people. Instead of running after the grades other students should also learn from these guys. And this is specifically what companies try to find in the candidates appearing for the interview. Dream jobs does not and should not depend upon the grades only!

18 Aug 2017, 01.28 AM

Mini Mock Test

CUET-PG Mini Mock 2 (By TISS Mumbai HRM&LR)

Participants: 398

CUET-PG Mini Mock 3 (By TISS Mumbai HRM&LR)

Participants: 174
InsideIIM Gold - Q&A
WATPI S04 (Quiz)

CUET-PG Mini Mock 1 (By TISS Mumbai HRM&LR)

Participants: 763

MBA Admissions 2024 - WAT 1

Participants: 213

SNAP Quantitative Skills

Participants: 511

SNAP Quant - 1

Participants: 948
College Comparison Tool - Quiz Ad

SNAP VARC Mini Mock - 1

Participants: 938

SNAP Quant Mini Mock - 2

Participants: 355

SNAP DILR Mini Mock - 4

Participants: 242

SNAP VARC Mini Mock - 2

Participants: 436

SNAP Quant Mini Mock - 4

Participants: 186

SNAP LR Mini Mock - 3

Participants: 246

SNAP Quant Mini Mock - 3

Participants: 205

SNAP VARC Mini Mock - 3

Participants: 295

SNAP - Quant Mini Mock 5

Participants: 52

XAT Decision Making 2020

Participants: 445

XAT Decision Making 2019

Participants: 348

XAT Decision Making 2018

Participants: 447

XAT Decision Making -10

Participants: 584

XAT Decision Making -11

Participants: 456

XAT Decision Making - 12

Participants: 417

XAT Decision Making - 13

Participants: 352

XAT Decision Making - 14

Participants: 354

XAT Decision Making - 15

Participants: 395

XAT Decision Making - 16

Participants: 467

XAT Decision Making - 17

Participants: 511

XAT Decision Making 2021

Participants: 516

LR Topic Test

Participants: 2714

DI Topic Test

Participants: 1232

ParaSummary Topic Test

Participants: 2063

Take Free Test Here

Comments
 

K D

Policy Analyst

Does the dream FMCG company know that Nayan has learnt absolutely nothing in the 2 years he has spent in B-school and whose best skill is to bullshit his way through life?

14 Aug 2017, 06.36 PM

+Read Replies (5)

InsideIIM Counselling

Admin

The company probably trusts its own training over what professors at IIM Teach. Also, most companies look for aptitude and what really matters to them is whether they have cleared the CAT well and were decent enough to get an admit. Post that, the truth is that many companies don't care about whether the person does well academically at B-School.

14 Aug 2017, 06.43 PM |

InsideIIM Counselling

Admin

We would also point out the academic inflation in the employment market. Most jobs offered at B-Schools can be done by those who have an undergrad degree. However, the quality of undergrad degrees is so bad that everyone has to go to B-School to be employable. Not sure if B-School does that but it definitely ensures that there is a rigorous filtering criteria which makes the job of hiring for a lot of companies very easy. Then the company trainings and management trainee programmes, internships, rotations etc. which take over.

14 Aug 2017, 06.45 PM |

K D

Policy Analyst

So if I understand correctly, the rich literature of management education, taken from economics, finance, psychology, sociology, ethics etc., is of so little use in the complex and varied roles in industry and solving Class 10 math sums and basic comprehension so rigorous an indicator of 'aptitude', that all fresh entrants need to do is go through some internship primers, keep their head above water and talk shop during interviews, not to mention be sharp about fetching coffees during the summer internship?

14 Aug 2017, 07.21 PM |

InsideIIM Counselling

Admin

The truth lies somewhere in the middle. Driven management students will do the work expected of them but in the industry the companies rely on on their own training. Sad but true. Barring a few good business schools, a lot of tier-2 schools (and maybe even a few tier-1 schools) have very little of the 'riches' to offer.

14 Aug 2017, 07.44 PM |

K D

Policy Analyst

The only thing sad here is the lack of integrity being peddled as realism here. The rest, about what the industry wants and what the various tiers of b-schools have to offer is just lazy conjecture. A stark reminder on the eve of our Independence Day that corruption starts at the top.

15 Aug 2017, 08.12 AM |

Manojit Basak

Nayan is THE perfect example of what an mba graduate should be. He did manage both his time and efforts efficiently as well as effectively. Theoritical knowledge can be gained at any stage in life but managing the work in hand with this efficiency needs to be learnt from these particular people. Instead of running after the grades other students should also learn from these guys. And this is specifically what companies try to find in the candidates appearing for the interview. Dream jobs does not and should not depend upon the grades only!

18 Aug 2017, 01.28 AM