MBA is one of the most sought after courses in India. But recently they are under much criticism due to hefty fees and low return on investment (ROI). But this article is not to criticize MBA but to weigh pros and cons of doing MBA. Though MBA involves a significant amount of money with huge tuition fees and with it comes the huge stress of assignments, exams, competition, CGPA, placements. But there are benefits also both monetary and non-monetary such as good career avenues, high salary, corporate networks, and most importantly inner strength to survive. I will begin with criticism against MBA

 

Why MBA is not worth?

 

Tuition fees

MBA is not as cheap as other courses. The tuition fees currently being charged for MBA both in India and outside India is hefty and even after economic meltdown it is increasing. In US the tuition and hostel fees in continuously increasing from 1973. In India also, most of the older IIMs have increased their fees 3 to 4 times. But with such heavy fees, most of the prestigious colleges offer financial aids and scholarships. In India every IIM has financial aids up to 100% ready for students who belong to economically backward class.

 

Opportunity cost

Other than tuition fees and other cost of doing an MBA there is also an implicit cost associated with doing an MBA i.e. loss of job benefits, the financial and career opportunities lost in 2 years of doing an MBA. But this loss is offset by the pay hike. Official GMAT website claims that on an average MBA aspirants can expect 55% increase in their salary, whatever they were getting before doing MBA.

 

Living Expenses

Living cost is another major cost which dig a big hole in pockets of MBA students. The average of total living cost is almost same in Asia-pacific region and Europe – approx. $70,000. But in USA an MBA student needs to spend around $99,000 (Financial Times Survey, 2014). Though it is much cheaper in India but we can expect around 4-5 lakhs for 2 years. (Personal estimate)

 

Other expenses

Stationary, Foreign exchange program are cost which one needs to count

 

Non-Monetary costs

The stress you go through during 2 grueling years cannot be measured in money. There is no work life balance, you don’t have time for your personal relationships. The only things you end up doing is Group assignments, giving exams and pre reads for next class. High level of competition can also leave destroy one’s self confidence.

 

 

Benefits of doing an MBA

Every MBA student has a dream deep inside his heart of becoming CEO of some reputed company. It is really exciting for an MBA student to know that out of 500 fortune companies 200 companies have MBA graduates as their CEO.

 

Exciting Career Avenues

The most important benefit which MBA on resume provides a candidate are the exciting career opportunities. For a successful career, your starting in corporate world is of prime importance. This is the reason why many fresher prefer MBA over lucrative job offer.

The graph below shows the domain in which currently IIM A alums are working. These graphs clearly show that doing an MBA can prove to be a great asset and can land you C-levels of corporate executives.

Doing an MBA also provides you a diverse set of domains to choose from. MBA pass outs get a wide array of roles in senior and middle level managers in diverse industries to choose from.

 

iim a 1
Current Job titles of IIM A alums
iim a 2
Current Job sectors of IIM A alums

Pay Hike

The other most important benefit which an MBA degree provides is the pay hike. According to financial times  survey an IIM A graduate gets a pay hike of 140%. For foreign B-schools such as HBS it is 122%.
The table below shows the ROI of different class of business school. This table was presented in GMAC survey of 2013.

gmma

Corporate networking

MBA’s are best known for the network which you develop in 2 years. It is even said in many HBR articles that networking is most important trait of a successful manager. Most of the top B-schools have large alumni base which help graduates of these colleges to excel in real world.

Job security

One more benefit which comes with an MBA degree is high level of employability. Doing an MBA increase your probability of securing a good job.

Non-monetary benefits

Along with all these monetary benefits comes a pride of holding an MBA degree from a prestigious institute. The knowledge which you get, the personality development which happens in 2 years of MBA, the self-confidence and survival skills which it develops contribute a lot to success of an individual.

Conclusion

Though the criticism of MBA has been galloping in recent years. But with financial turmoil in world economy one cannot expect MBA grads to be unaffected, it is simple play of demand and supply.

However the knowledge base and benefits provided by an MBA degree cannot be compared with any other course which we have in our current education system. MBA is by-far the best course which anyone who aspires of a successful corporate life can do.

MBA is not just a degree, it teaches you the how to manage your life in a much better way. The experience and the learning which it provides cannot be priced.

 

——–

I am an IPM participant of IIM Indore currently pursuing first year of MBA. During my last 4 years in IIM Indore I have got deep insights of how things work in an MBA college and have a gained a lot of knowledge. I would not have got such a wonderful experience if i would have joined any other course.

Comments