Competitions
CAT Prep
Upskill
Placements
MBA Co'26
RTI Response
Rankings
Score Vs. %ile
Salaries
Campus Tour

Battle 2 : IIM Ahmedabad vs IIM Bangalore – Increase in batch sizes at top B schools in India is justified (AGAINST)

Comments
 

Mihir Mehta

Good stuff IIM B! This will be tough to beat!

4 Aug 2012, 01.13 PM

Aman

IIM A need to be more rational and quantitative while they make arguments. If the argument is good, better accept it rather than stating the premise as flawed, it's baseless and immature. If it is flawed, prove it!

4 Aug 2012, 03.37 PM

Raghavendra

People who enter the IIMs do realise their standing and appropriately choose a sector where they will excel. The predisposition towards MNCs disappears and people serious asl themselves the question as to what kind of job do they really want. Unfortunately large batch sizes mean the person wanting a particular sector doesn't even get it because of sheer number of students. It may not be very apparent in IIMA and B but certainly does become clear in I and L

4 Aug 2012, 08.13 PM

Aakanksha

We all are aware of the winner between quality v/s quantity debate. IIM B did a great job in pointing the same in an articulate way.

4 Aug 2012, 08.38 PM

IIMer

IIM Lucknow fee is 12.5 lakhs. Data incorrect IIMB ..!!!

4 Aug 2012, 08.53 PM

Shravani

1. IIMA in you opening argument you had advocated the establisment o newer IIMs. Now you say that IIMBs argument in favor of the same is flawed. That itself is contradictory. Even you would agree that the old IIMs cannot go on increasing their seats forever. The newer IIMs have to start taking over the responsibility of manufacturing more managers. The sooner the better. Worse infrastructureis only the stepping stones for better ones. All new IIMs have exclusive campuses sanctioned by their state governments 2. The size of the group has also increased . I can vouch for that and it touches a chord in my heart because I am a constant victim od free-riding:)

4 Aug 2012, 08.59 PM

Nonsense

Dear InsideIIM, Instead of having these topics, can we have topics where the debate/discussion is focused on entrepreneurship, emerging sectors and all. What are we achieving with these discussions. We will not derive any value from these discussions. What roles B-schools can/will play in tackling our society's problems.

5 Aug 2012, 04.55 PM

+Read Replies (1)

@InsideIIM

Have patience. The Semi-Finals and the Finals are still to take place. A lot will be explored. Also, we do not believe that any of the topics here are pointless. These topics will help thousands of students get a holistic view of the situation before deciding to invest in a MBA/Higher education. Some of the arguments here have been argued very well by the teams with good amount of research. This perspective wasn't available to students and potential aspirants even 3-4 years back.

5 Aug 2012, 05.14 PM |

ASHISH

The OBC population captured in by IIM A fellows is flawed. For instance due to vote back politics everyone in TN is educationally backward other than 2%. How is that possible as TN claims to be leading in education space. Fact is Many castes have been included into OBC due to political pressure. Look at the latest case of Jats in Haryana. The speakers for the motion look like have come from OBC quota. It's mostly southern states which are getting benefitted because of the quota. In AIIMS majority of OBC quota is greeting filled from Kerala. Purely going by IIMA guys logic , majority of seats in premier institutes should go to either UP, Bihar because of population proportion. But they wont say that as it hurts. This wholly flawed system has taken a huge toll on quality of students and killed the creativity quotient and joy of campus life

25 Jan 2013, 11.11 AM

Mini Mock Test

Final 18 Days to CAT 2024 Test-28

Participants: 18

Final 19 Days to CAT 2024 Test-26

Participants: 157
College Comparison Tool - Quiz Ad

Final 20 Days to CAT 2024 Test-26

Participants: 183

Final 21 Days to CAT 2024 Test-25

Participants: 148

Final 22 Days to CAT 2024 Test-24

Participants: 167

Final 23 Days to CAT 2024 Test-23

Participants: 105

Final 24 Days to CAT 2024 Test-22

Participants: 157

Final 25 Days to CAT 2024 Test-21

Participants: 146

Final 26 Days to CAT 2024 Test-20

Participants: 197

Final 27 Days to CAT 2024 Test-19

Participants: 171

Final 28 Days to CAT 2024 Test-18

Participants: 169

Final 29 Days to CAT 2024 Test-17

Participants: 176

Final 30 Days to CAT 2024 Test-16

Participants: 195

Final 31 Days to CAT 2024 Test-15

Participants: 185

Final 32 Days to CAT 2024 Test-14

Participants: 195

Final 33 Days to CAT 2024 Test-13

Participants: 196

Final 34 Days to CAT 2024 Test-12

Participants: 228

CAT 2017 VARC SLOT- 2

Participants: 313

CAT 2017 DILR SLOT- 2

Participants: 157

CAT 2017 VARC SLOT- 1

Participants: 301

CAT 2017 DILR SLOT- 1

Participants: 106

CAT 2017 QUANT SLOT 1

Participants: 152

CAT 2017 QUANT SLOT 2

Participants: 69

CAT 2018 QUANT SLOT 2

Participants: 67

CAT 2018 QUANT SLOT 1

Participants: 108

CAT 2018 DILR SLOT- 2

Participants: 58

CAT 2018 DILR SLOT- 1

Participants: 84

CAT 2018 VARC SLOT- 2

Participants: 203

CAT 2018 VARC SLOT- 1

Participants: 298

Final 35 Days to CAT 2024 Test-11

Participants: 157

Take Free Test Here

Comments
 

Mihir Mehta

Good stuff IIM B! This will be tough to beat!

4 Aug 2012, 01.13 PM

Aman

IIM A need to be more rational and quantitative while they make arguments. If the argument is good, better accept it rather than stating the premise as flawed, it's baseless and immature. If it is flawed, prove it!

4 Aug 2012, 03.37 PM

Raghavendra

People who enter the IIMs do realise their standing and appropriately choose a sector where they will excel. The predisposition towards MNCs disappears and people serious asl themselves the question as to what kind of job do they really want. Unfortunately large batch sizes mean the person wanting a particular sector doesn't even get it because of sheer number of students. It may not be very apparent in IIMA and B but certainly does become clear in I and L

4 Aug 2012, 08.13 PM

Aakanksha

We all are aware of the winner between quality v/s quantity debate. IIM B did a great job in pointing the same in an articulate way.

4 Aug 2012, 08.38 PM

IIMer

IIM Lucknow fee is 12.5 lakhs. Data incorrect IIMB ..!!!

4 Aug 2012, 08.53 PM

Shravani

1. IIMA in you opening argument you had advocated the establisment o newer IIMs. Now you say that IIMBs argument in favor of the same is flawed. That itself is contradictory. Even you would agree that the old IIMs cannot go on increasing their seats forever. The newer IIMs have to start taking over the responsibility of manufacturing more managers. The sooner the better. Worse infrastructureis only the stepping stones for better ones. All new IIMs have exclusive campuses sanctioned by their state governments 2. The size of the group has also increased . I can vouch for that and it touches a chord in my heart because I am a constant victim od free-riding:)

4 Aug 2012, 08.59 PM

Nonsense

Dear InsideIIM, Instead of having these topics, can we have topics where the debate/discussion is focused on entrepreneurship, emerging sectors and all. What are we achieving with these discussions. We will not derive any value from these discussions. What roles B-schools can/will play in tackling our society's problems.

5 Aug 2012, 04.55 PM

+Read Replies (1)

@InsideIIM

Have patience. The Semi-Finals and the Finals are still to take place. A lot will be explored. Also, we do not believe that any of the topics here are pointless. These topics will help thousands of students get a holistic view of the situation before deciding to invest in a MBA/Higher education. Some of the arguments here have been argued very well by the teams with good amount of research. This perspective wasn't available to students and potential aspirants even 3-4 years back.

5 Aug 2012, 05.14 PM |

ASHISH

The OBC population captured in by IIM A fellows is flawed. For instance due to vote back politics everyone in TN is educationally backward other than 2%. How is that possible as TN claims to be leading in education space. Fact is Many castes have been included into OBC due to political pressure. Look at the latest case of Jats in Haryana. The speakers for the motion look like have come from OBC quota. It's mostly southern states which are getting benefitted because of the quota. In AIIMS majority of OBC quota is greeting filled from Kerala. Purely going by IIMA guys logic , majority of seats in premier institutes should go to either UP, Bihar because of population proportion. But they wont say that as it hurts. This wholly flawed system has taken a huge toll on quality of students and killed the creativity quotient and joy of campus life

25 Jan 2013, 11.11 AM