CAT Prep
RTI Response
Rankings
Placements
Score Vs. %ile
Salaries
Campus Tour
Upskill
Career Show

IIM Calcutta breaks its own record: 441 placed in 3 days

Comments
 

Sunny Talreja

The article highlights everything wrong with the placements in IIMS... whether its Summers or Finals... If 155 firms actually recruited 441 participants in three days, that means an average of 51 firms a day... how did any participant got enough time for proper representation and how did those recruitment agency got enough time for proper selection... participant doesn't care about the firm... firm doesn't care about the participant or his/her interests... everyone just wanna get it over. Assuming the event took even 7 days (three placement days, one zero day and three negative day), the argument still holds true.

10 Nov 2013, 08.30 PM

+Read Replies (4)

yeshwant yeshwant

First of all i would like to know if you are from any of the IIM , if not I would advise you to keep your logic to yourself. There is a very thorough process that goes on months before the actual placement date and it is not as if the recruiters were informed that they have to catch the flight the next day. This is IIM for godsake and your argument is absolutely wrong .

10 Nov 2013, 09.08 PM |

Pritish Ekka

You shout it out, But I can't hear a word you say I'm talking loud not saying much I'm criticized but all your bullets ricochet You shoot me down, but I get up I'm bulletproof, nothing to lose Fire away, fire away Ricochet, you take your aim Fire away, fire away You shoot me down but I won't fall I am titanium................

Lol ignorance Is bliss. Dude placement process is not so simple process as you explained. I would suggest you to talk to talk to some IIM grad to know More Instead of assuming some weird reasoning.

10 Nov 2013, 10.27 PM |

Sunny Talreja

well I am from am IIM and know this process very well. No matter how many months you plan in advance... if your top priority was to finish everything in three days.. that shows your concern about matching the job profile with requirements.

11 Nov 2013, 01.03 AM |

Sunny Talreja

I second your thought... Ignorance is bliss... Maybe that's why, you didn't even cared to click on my profile to check whether i am from an IIM or not. Again, instead of being over protective about your summers process, you could have tried to infer the reasoning behind my comment. Now tell me Pritesh, what is more important, completing process in three days or matching the job profile correctly because the headline and claims made by your ER cell portrays summers as merely a grueling task and your placement committee's ultimate success is being able to achieve it in three days...

11 Nov 2013, 01.13 AM |

Krish H

I strongly feel that this is sheer boasting about oneself. Being an IIM, there is no need to showcase the world that you too survived well as the world expects you to fare well. Just being an established IIM, I think, the students are enjoying the fruits !! No offence to anyone. Anyways, congrats!!

11 Nov 2013, 12.07 AM

+Read Replies (2)

Ankit Upadhyay

"Just being an established IIM, I think, the students are enjoying the fruits"...... just a small doubt.?..... u know that the students didn't get there through lottery?.... right?...

11 Nov 2013, 01.20 AM |

yeshwant yeshwant

I seriously do not get what is it that you want to get across ? You have no idea about the hardwork that goes into achieving something of this sort ...and yes the students enjoy the fruits of their hardwork and nothing else !!!

11 Nov 2013, 01.35 AM |

Rohit Baheti

@Yeshwant - Please keep the 'hardworking' bit to only the top 250-300 students. There are so many who have got in to IIM C because they have a caste certificate despite being from very wealthy families. And did I mention extra marks for women? And these days getting in an IIM is matter of chance than ability as selection criterias are such that with 99.xx percentile also you wont get a call. So what krish581 says is right. What Sunny Talreja says is also correct - You can keep bragging about placements finished in 3 days but this process will result in so many unhappy souls and people who will quit their jobs within the first 6 months of joining.

11 Nov 2013, 10.44 AM

+Read Replies (1)

yeshwant yeshwant

Looks like you guys hate IIM so much that you come up with some new reasons to bash. If you have a problem with reservations then fight with the government , what do the IIM's have to do with it ? Although I agree that selection to some extent is flawed and a few deserving candidates may not get through , it doesn't mean that the whole system is flawed. Although I get the point about the 3 days thing , saying rubbish that getting into IIM is a matter of chance is either due to your ignorance or because you couldn't make into of the IIM.

11 Nov 2013, 01.06 PM |

Krish H

I just want to emphasize that the students or alumni of IIMs are not gods.....they are just common people like us. Some incidents happened in the past couple of years have proved that literally on the lines of drug addiction, professors harassment et al. Offending anyone is not my intention though. After all, getting big packages or cracking the so called dumb big companies is not the value added in life. It is that how much value we add to the society that matters !!

11 Nov 2013, 02.38 PM

+Read Replies (2)

yeshwant yeshwant

@krish581 your point is well taken. But I'd advise you to spend your time usefully by contributing to the society rather than wasting your time arguing here. And yes the the alums of IIM's are no gods and no one claims that either , they are just normal people like you and me who dream big and are ready to put in all that it takes, to achieve it.

11 Nov 2013, 11.05 PM |

Krish H

lol.....who asked your advice ?? First learn how to speak and understand the viewpoints rather than giving advice to others. I just expressed my opinion and I haven't offended anyone.

12 Nov 2013, 07.28 PM |

Manish Jain

Can we have details around number of offers made by top consulting firms?

12 Nov 2013, 12.10 PM

Mini Mock Test

CUET-PG Mini Mock 2 (By TISS Mumbai HRM&LR)

Participants: 409

CUET-PG Mini Mock 3 (By TISS Mumbai HRM&LR)

Participants: 176
InsideIIM Gold - Q&A
WATPI S04 (Quiz)

CUET-PG Mini Mock 1 (By TISS Mumbai HRM&LR)

Participants: 768

MBA Admissions 2024 - WAT 1

Participants: 224

SNAP Quantitative Skills

Participants: 514

SNAP Quant - 1

Participants: 950
College Comparison Tool - Quiz Ad

SNAP VARC Mini Mock - 1

Participants: 942

SNAP Quant Mini Mock - 2

Participants: 357

SNAP DILR Mini Mock - 4

Participants: 243

SNAP VARC Mini Mock - 2

Participants: 437

SNAP Quant Mini Mock - 4

Participants: 187

SNAP LR Mini Mock - 3

Participants: 249

SNAP Quant Mini Mock - 3

Participants: 206

SNAP VARC Mini Mock - 3

Participants: 297

SNAP - Quant Mini Mock 5

Participants: 52

XAT Decision Making 2020

Participants: 447

XAT Decision Making 2019

Participants: 349

XAT Decision Making 2018

Participants: 448

XAT Decision Making -10

Participants: 585

XAT Decision Making -11

Participants: 456

XAT Decision Making - 12

Participants: 417

XAT Decision Making - 13

Participants: 352

XAT Decision Making - 14

Participants: 354

XAT Decision Making - 15

Participants: 395

XAT Decision Making - 16

Participants: 468

XAT Decision Making - 17

Participants: 511

XAT Decision Making 2021

Participants: 517

LR Topic Test

Participants: 2727

DI Topic Test

Participants: 1234

ParaSummary Topic Test

Participants: 2088

Take Free Test Here

Comments
 

Sunny Talreja

The article highlights everything wrong with the placements in IIMS... whether its Summers or Finals... If 155 firms actually recruited 441 participants in three days, that means an average of 51 firms a day... how did any participant got enough time for proper representation and how did those recruitment agency got enough time for proper selection... participant doesn't care about the firm... firm doesn't care about the participant or his/her interests... everyone just wanna get it over. Assuming the event took even 7 days (three placement days, one zero day and three negative day), the argument still holds true.

10 Nov 2013, 08.30 PM

+Read Replies (4)

yeshwant yeshwant

First of all i would like to know if you are from any of the IIM , if not I would advise you to keep your logic to yourself. There is a very thorough process that goes on months before the actual placement date and it is not as if the recruiters were informed that they have to catch the flight the next day. This is IIM for godsake and your argument is absolutely wrong .

10 Nov 2013, 09.08 PM |

Pritish Ekka

You shout it out, But I can't hear a word you say I'm talking loud not saying much I'm criticized but all your bullets ricochet You shoot me down, but I get up I'm bulletproof, nothing to lose Fire away, fire away Ricochet, you take your aim Fire away, fire away You shoot me down but I won't fall I am titanium................

Lol ignorance Is bliss. Dude placement process is not so simple process as you explained. I would suggest you to talk to talk to some IIM grad to know More Instead of assuming some weird reasoning.

10 Nov 2013, 10.27 PM |

Sunny Talreja

well I am from am IIM and know this process very well. No matter how many months you plan in advance... if your top priority was to finish everything in three days.. that shows your concern about matching the job profile with requirements.

11 Nov 2013, 01.03 AM |

Sunny Talreja

I second your thought... Ignorance is bliss... Maybe that's why, you didn't even cared to click on my profile to check whether i am from an IIM or not. Again, instead of being over protective about your summers process, you could have tried to infer the reasoning behind my comment. Now tell me Pritesh, what is more important, completing process in three days or matching the job profile correctly because the headline and claims made by your ER cell portrays summers as merely a grueling task and your placement committee's ultimate success is being able to achieve it in three days...

11 Nov 2013, 01.13 AM |

Krish H

I strongly feel that this is sheer boasting about oneself. Being an IIM, there is no need to showcase the world that you too survived well as the world expects you to fare well. Just being an established IIM, I think, the students are enjoying the fruits !! No offence to anyone. Anyways, congrats!!

11 Nov 2013, 12.07 AM

+Read Replies (2)

Ankit Upadhyay

"Just being an established IIM, I think, the students are enjoying the fruits"...... just a small doubt.?..... u know that the students didn't get there through lottery?.... right?...

11 Nov 2013, 01.20 AM |

yeshwant yeshwant

I seriously do not get what is it that you want to get across ? You have no idea about the hardwork that goes into achieving something of this sort ...and yes the students enjoy the fruits of their hardwork and nothing else !!!

11 Nov 2013, 01.35 AM |

Rohit Baheti

@Yeshwant - Please keep the 'hardworking' bit to only the top 250-300 students. There are so many who have got in to IIM C because they have a caste certificate despite being from very wealthy families. And did I mention extra marks for women? And these days getting in an IIM is matter of chance than ability as selection criterias are such that with 99.xx percentile also you wont get a call. So what krish581 says is right. What Sunny Talreja says is also correct - You can keep bragging about placements finished in 3 days but this process will result in so many unhappy souls and people who will quit their jobs within the first 6 months of joining.

11 Nov 2013, 10.44 AM

+Read Replies (1)

yeshwant yeshwant

Looks like you guys hate IIM so much that you come up with some new reasons to bash. If you have a problem with reservations then fight with the government , what do the IIM's have to do with it ? Although I agree that selection to some extent is flawed and a few deserving candidates may not get through , it doesn't mean that the whole system is flawed. Although I get the point about the 3 days thing , saying rubbish that getting into IIM is a matter of chance is either due to your ignorance or because you couldn't make into of the IIM.

11 Nov 2013, 01.06 PM |

Krish H

I just want to emphasize that the students or alumni of IIMs are not gods.....they are just common people like us. Some incidents happened in the past couple of years have proved that literally on the lines of drug addiction, professors harassment et al. Offending anyone is not my intention though. After all, getting big packages or cracking the so called dumb big companies is not the value added in life. It is that how much value we add to the society that matters !!

11 Nov 2013, 02.38 PM

+Read Replies (2)

yeshwant yeshwant

@krish581 your point is well taken. But I'd advise you to spend your time usefully by contributing to the society rather than wasting your time arguing here. And yes the the alums of IIM's are no gods and no one claims that either , they are just normal people like you and me who dream big and are ready to put in all that it takes, to achieve it.

11 Nov 2013, 11.05 PM |

Krish H

lol.....who asked your advice ?? First learn how to speak and understand the viewpoints rather than giving advice to others. I just expressed my opinion and I haven't offended anyone.

12 Nov 2013, 07.28 PM |

Manish Jain

Can we have details around number of offers made by top consulting firms?

12 Nov 2013, 12.10 PM