WATPI Prep

XAT/ OMET

Interview Experiences

Admissions

Upskill

Placements

RTI Response

Rankings

Score Vs. %ile

Salaries

Gems of Joka - Manish Ghiya - Chartered Accountant at IIM Calcutta

Nov 27, 2013 | 4 minutes |

Join InsideIIM GOLD

Webinars & Workshops

Compare B-Schools

Free CAT Course

Take Free Mock Tests

Upskill With AltUni

CAT Study Planner

SNAP Mock 10: Based on Slot 1&2 2024

Participants: 933

SNAP Mock 9: Based on Slot 1&2 2024

Participants: 522

SNAP Mock 8: Based on Slot 1&2 2024

Participants: 404

SNAP Mock 7: Based on Slot 1&2 2024

Participants: 343

SNAP Mock 6: Based on Slot 1&2 2024

Participants: 356

SNAP Mock 5: Based on Slot 1&2 2024

Participants: 474

SNAP Mock 4: Based on Slot 1&2 2024

Participants: 557

SNAP Mock 3: Based on Slot 1&2 2024

Participants: 735

SNAP Mock 2: Based on Slot 1&2 2024

Participants: 1034

SNAP Mock 1: Based on Slot 1&2 2024

Participants: 1679

XAT 2018 General Knowledge

Participants: 37

XAT 2019 General Knowledge

Participants: 9

XAT 2024 General Knowledge

Participants: 56

XAT 2018

Participants: 25

XAT 2019

Participants: 5

XAT Decision Making 2018

Participants: 586

XAT 2024 Decision Making

Participants: 57

XAT 2024

Participants: 38

XAT Decision Making 2021

Participants: 605

XAT 2021

Participants: 21

XAT 2021 Decision Making

Participants: 25

XAT 2023 Decision Making

Participants: 42

XAT 2022

Participants: 20

XAT 2022 Decision Making

Participants: 42

XAT 2023

Participants: 30

XAT 2020

Participants: 15

XAT 2020 Decision Making

Participants: 25

XAT 2023 General Knowledge

Participants: 39

XAT 2022 General Knowledge

Participants: 21

XAT 2021 General Knowledge

Participants: 18

Continuing our series on InsideIIM.com where we profile interesting creatures on the Joka campus. This is the fifth story in this series. Today, we meet a Chartered Accountant at IIM Calcutta. (You can read the stories of other Chartered Accountants here)   Tell us about your background I was born in Rajasthan and brought up in Kolkata. I come from a business family. My father is a businessman. We traded in home textiles, specifically handkerchiefs and napkins. I went to St Xavier’s College, Kolkata where I did my B.Com Honors, specializing in Accounting. In the meantime I also pursued my Chartered Accountancy. I worked for an audit firm in Central Kolkata for 2 years after completing my article-ship over there.  
  Tell us about your time in the family business. It all started as a pastime during summer vacations when I was in school. But soon, due to family reasons, I had to shoulder some responsibilities over there and then I became a full-timer. I handled various functions in the firm, like procurement, sales, accounting and so on. It was hard for me to continue higher education as a lot of my time had to be invested in the family enterprise. However, I chose not to give up my education and pursued Chartered Accountancy on the side. I cleared my Level-1 with distinction. Then the family business was split and I helped my father to set up a new business from scratch. Now we are among the top 5 firms in Kolkata.    How did you start your auditing career? As part of my CA curriculum, I started my article-ship with DK Paramanandka & Co. Under the aegis of the partner, I learned the practical applications of what I learnt in my CA curriculum. An article-ship is like an internship or an apprenticeship where one gets hands-on experience with respect to internal audit, statutory audit, managerial and taxation consultancy.   What was the most significant thing you did as an auditor? One of the most significant experiences that I had was leading an audit assignment on the very first day of my article-ship. I conducted a bank audit, was given only a short brief of my deliverables. Now, I already knew about the functioning of a bank as an outsider but lacked practical exposure. I started with trying to figure out key critical points in the business blueprint of a bank & made them the focus of my audit. This led me to generate specific insights about  possible tools & techniques to be used to verify the Non-Performing Asset classification & calculations. Apart from this, various issues like verifying the computation of depreciation, wage bills, form 15G/15H (with respect to TDS computation), compiling the Long-Form Audit report (which meets RBI compliance requirements) provided me the ideal first assignment. So was anything off in the banks’ books J ? I am not at liberty to reveal such details of my assignments ;)   So what brings you to MBA and IIM Calcutta? So at an audit firm you work with figures with little knowledge of how to create them. My rationale was that an MBA would help me create businesses that would in turn generate those numbers. I also want to do something of my own in the future, something bigger than my father’s enterprise. And what better place to do this than IIM Calcutta    Why do you think there are very few CAs in IIMs? Firstly there are very few CAs out there, unlike engineers. Also, there is a conflict of incentives. A CA can make anywhere between 8-10 lakhs with his own practice and enjoys a lot of job stability, even in managerial positions. Life is quite “chill” so to speak. So a CA has little reason to spend over 13.5 lakh, forego 2 years of wages and then apply for a job all over again.    So what is next? In the short-term, I am looking to continue my career in Finance. I want to get a job in Corporate Finance or Commercial Banking. After getting enough exposure I would like to start a boutique finance firm of my own.   as told to Afzal Hussain   (You can read the stories of other Chartered Accountants here)   Afzal Hussain is a student at IIM Calcutta (Class of 2014). He did his BE degree from Birla Institute of Technology Mesra in Electrical and Electronic Engineering and worked as an IT Consultant in Deloitte for 2 years after that. He enjoys reading everything under the sun, listens to Apertura by Gustavo Santaolalla on loop and worships Fight Club. Follow Afzal at afzal.insideiim.com Follow IIM Calcutta at iimc.insideiim.com, For other Gems of Joka – Click here Read Interview Experiences in the Finance and Banking domain here