- Diversity of academic disciplines has been given prime importance. If you are in the top 1% as per your CAT score in your academic discipline among the 5 identified by IIM Ahmedabad, you will immediately get a call provided you have 90%ile overall and 85% in each section. Clearly, the number of engineers at IIM A will fall. The last two years have had over 95% engineers. It will fall to close to 70% from next year as per our estimates. Engineers are bound to feel a little aggrieved.
- No favour for girls. No extra marks for gender.
- No advantage for having work experience when being shortlisted
- If one reads the criteria for Stage 1c, it still has the fundamental flaw which everyone has been crying about for the last 2 years to some extent. Students from boards that throw marks will be benefited. However, the degree of advantage has reduced. So someone with 90+ marks will still be given more marks without any normalization but the degree of weight has been reduced. Application rating is now much more fair as it is not multiplicative like the last 2 years
The 5 academic disciplines identified by IIM A are on page 8 and 9 of this document
Test Case 1 : Arts Graduate gets 99%ile
Let us assume this Arts graduate gets 99%ile with 85%ile+ in both sections.
His 10th,12th,15th scores are : 85%,82% and 77%.
Now, 77% in an Humanities stream is excellent graduation percentage. In many universities, such an individual could be a topper. However, since IIM A is allergic to normalization, this person would have never got an IIM A call as per last year's criteria. Even people with lesser %ile than this person and with a grad score 85% had a better chance to qualify. The old criteria was unfavourable to this person and students from universities and streams which throw marks would benefit.
Now, provided this person is among the top 1% or among the top 50 candidates, whichever is lower, in his academic discipline, he will immediately get a call.
He will get a call even if he has 95%ile but is among the top 50 candidates in his discipline.
This criteria is unlikely to look at the category the person belongs to at this stage. There is no clarity on it in the criteria.
Test Case 2 : Engineer gets 99.6%ile
Let us assume this person gets 99.6%ile with 85%ile+ in both sections.
His 10th,12th,15th scores are also 85%,82% and 77%.
Now it is unlikely that an engineer with 99.6%ile will be among the top 50 candidates in his discipline. Hence, getting a call through Stage 1b as applied to the Arts graduate above is out of question for this person. Based on history of the CAT, the top 50 candidates in the Engineering discipline will close above 99.9%ile
Hence, stage 1c will be applied to this person.
Let us start with the Application Rating.
His/Her application rating will be :
(0.5*7)+ (1.5*7) +(2.5*7) = 3 + 10.5 + 17.5 = 31 out of a total of 45
Now, this person's composite score which is used to shortlist people would be :
Assume 99.6%ile is a scaled score of 300 out of 450 ,
70% weight to CAT will yield = (300/450) * 0.7 = 0.46666
30% weight to Application Rating = (31/45) * 0.3 = 0.20666
Total 0.673333 out of a maximum of 1
Now, let us assume that IIM A will call 400 general category candidates over and above the general category candidates from the 250 called as per criteria in Stage 1b.
Provided, the score of 0.6733333 is among the top 400 this person may get a call.
Our friend's at the Media Cell at IIM Ahmedabad have also written about the salient features of the IIM Ahmedabad's revised selection policy here
We will keep updating this space. Come back for more
Keep following our Live MBA Updates here
For last year's selection criteria, click here
Read everything about IIM A here
Our analysis of IIM Lucknow's criteria
Our analysis of IIM Kozhikode’s criteria
Our analysis of IIM Indore’s criteria
Meet us on Whatsapp: Get LIVE Updates on CAT 2013
For High Quality Interview Preparations
Final Frontier with Deepali Naair 2014-High Quality Interview Training
Online Interview Training with IIM Alumni-via-Skype Hangout/Telephone-2014
Chat
Comments