Competitions
CAT Prep
Upskill
Placements
MBA Co'26
RTI Response
Rankings
Score Vs. %ile
Salaries
Campus Tour

Summer Placements : IIM Indore – Class of 2012-14

Comments
 

Rohit

Good show. Many new names. Good to see some one give stipend distribution. Very good to see honesty in international offers figure. 12 is realistic. IIM K with 20 is definitely inflated. But I notice that slowdown has hit IIM I a little. I don't see BCG, Bank Of America Merrill Lynch, Accenture Management Consulting, J&J Consumer. They all recruited last year. In fact regular recruiter Standard Chartered Bank is also missing. TAS was always going to be a problem after what happened last year.

11 Dec 2012, 08.02 PM

+Read Replies (15)

IIM I Student

Well. You will see both BCG and Bank of America Merrill Lynch in the finals report in a couple of months from now. Don't really want to comment on the other misses.

11 Dec 2012, 08.10 PM |

FYI

Firms like BCG, McKinsey have hired in big numbers from the top campuses this year. BCG picked up 14 interns from IIMA, 12 each from IIMB and IIMC. Around 7 from IIML. A total of 45 interns from the top 4 IIMs. That is a huge number. Mckinsey again picked up 10 from IIMA, 11 from IIMB, 8 from IIMC, 6 from IIML i.e. around 35 interns from the top IIMs. Accenture picked up atleast 10 each from ABCL., a total of atleast 40 across the top 4 campuses. ATKearney infact added IIML to their campus list. All in all, big consulting firms are hiring big time. They are not really affected by the slowing economy. But they have cut on campuses and recruited in more numbers from their favourite campuses. It seems that they want to associate themselves only with the big and established brands.

12 Dec 2012, 06.03 PM |

abc

u forgot to mention xlri..BCG came there as well.

12 Dec 2012, 07.02 PM |

Vipul L

Nice try to improve PR of the college....I heard one of my Indore friend saying that there was literally no companies for over 200+ students. I was surprised after giving a sly look on this report. It looks as if they have beaten all the records. I am amazed on their proficiency to hide the real truth. Can you also clarify on the duration for summer placements this time?

12 Dec 2012, 07.50 PM |

Obvious

These firms take some time in convincing. You forget that IIM I is only 15 yrs old while other campuses are much older. Also you must consider that BCG is a regular recruiter at IIM I for finals and it should probably turn up for next summers or the one after that AMC turned up for last yrs summers at IIM I so once they have good numbers they will probably come back. With BCG coming, its only a matter of time before the other consults also start coming

13 Dec 2012, 01.35 AM |

Use Logic

@vipul - do you think the time required for summers is a good criteria for gauging the quality of placements? Dude - do you think that will 180+ companies giving offers they would have placed only 250?? Seriously? Ask any person in a B-School 180 companies are enough for 420-30 offers. you will find similar no of companies giving offers on other IIMs with similar batch sizes

13 Dec 2012, 01.40 AM |

Prabhu

Just to clarify....AT Kearney has not added IIML to the list. It has always been one of the 5 schools of choice as can be seen here - <a href="http://www.atkearney.com/careers/apply/india" rel="nofollow">http://www.atkearney.com/careers/apply/india</a>. And I have known for a fact that they recruited from there for the 2008 batch....

13 Dec 2012, 10.31 AM |

FYI

It does not recruit from IIML on a regular basis. It visits ABC every placement process. Nonetheless, thanks for the information.

13 Dec 2012, 12.48 PM |

question

No the point can you prove &quot;180 companies&quot; &quot;actually recruited&quot; from IIM I .......? #LogicFlawed

13 Dec 2012, 08.49 PM |

IIM student

its clearly written in the last graph that 181 companies gave offers. its also mentioned in their official release quoted on their site. and if u dnt believe that - dunno wat u will believe. Its a pity actually. Some people cant resist venting out their frustration on public forums

13 Dec 2012, 09.51 PM |

DontBelieveBS

well i also dont belive on this report too [ may it be OFFICIAL TOO ] .

14 Dec 2012, 05.05 AM |

question

No , i completely trust insideIIM.com , they are doing a great job, but they have there limitations too , there is no way in which they can verify whether 180 companies actually recruited , they simply print the report which is given to them by the placecom and there is no venting out of frustration , its just about finding out the truth so that aspirants don&#039;t get fooled by the rosy picture painted by students of premeir B schools and later regret their decision , which btw many people in IIM I are doing right nw .

14 Dec 2012, 08.38 PM |

Kudos_IIM I

Right now, most of the ppl at IIM I are celebrating their stellar summers (probably next to just 4-5 B Schools in the country). This coming from an IIM I student, I hope you won&#039;t believe this too. :P

14 Dec 2012, 09.13 PM |

LOL

LOL good 1!! next to just 4-5 B schools in the country :P LOL dude do you think students at countries top B schools believe those rankings u guys pay for ? :P we hav gt our brains and a common sense tooo :P

16 Dec 2012, 02.28 AM |

Logic

@LOL - u have some brains? wat a surprise coz it doesnt seem from your comments :P Anyways no IIM pays for his/her rankings as they are govt institutes

16 Dec 2012, 06.21 PM |

Vikas

Kudos to the placement committee for doing a great job till the end. 100 plus new companies is no joke. Also cheers for once again maintaining an ethical stand in reporting all figures and company names.

11 Dec 2012, 08.20 PM

finance

Over 40% in sales and marketing , says it all , its been a bad year for finance in all B schools with exception of IIM L , hope it improves till next year or many may reluctantly switch to marketing.

11 Dec 2012, 08.42 PM

question

Why are number of students signing out and Total no. of offers not disclosed ?? how does one come to know whether how many students actually got internship ?

11 Dec 2012, 08.46 PM

+Read Replies (1)

@InsideIIM

That is a problem. But there is no way we can get that information or even verify when someone does actually state a figure. IIM I, FMS and IIM K decided not to report that statistic. Even the ones who have reported, we can&#039;t realistically verify it. The best way to find this out is to speak to a student from the campus.

11 Dec 2012, 08.57 PM |

Flaneur

Kudos to the placement committee !! 100 new companies takes huge effort .

11 Dec 2012, 11.41 PM

@InsideIIM

That statement has no basis. Please exercise caution before writing such comments. Any such comparisons without data and basis will be deleted.

12 Dec 2012, 12.25 AM

Ritesh

Excellent job indeed.. Hope it continues in the finals as well

12 Dec 2012, 12.27 AM

Sceptic

Just way too much goody goody congratulations going on here. Let&#039;s not forget a lot of recruiters have not returned to campus this year for Summers. Someone mentioned it earlier. Whether it was bad strategy on Placement Committee&#039;s part or bad luck or whatever the truth is that the placements could have been better. No doubt people have worked hard to get the placements done but I find the congratulations here over the top. Be more realistic guys.

12 Dec 2012, 12.42 AM

RCH89

@ The Glaring Truth ... Lol ... That&#039;s the funniest comment I have come across in the recent times

12 Dec 2012, 02.34 AM

Subbu

Rosy picture....heard summers were pretty bad this time around at IIM I...spread over months while other IIMs finished it off in weeks

12 Dec 2012, 08.38 AM

+Read Replies (1)

Neutral_Junta

Bad as compared to ? Last year ? IIM ABCL ? I dont think its fair to compare I with ABCL which are older colleges and which have all the big consulting and fin firms recruiting regularly. However I can say good if the performance has been better than last summers. Many new companies came but many companies didn&#039;t as seen from last year&#039;s report. However looking at the reports last year and this year, the numbers seem better this year.

13 Dec 2012, 01.11 AM |

Rahul Kar

I am confused. Two of my friends study in the IIMI campus and they were telling me how bad the situation inside the campus is and common sense also says That Indore is not IIM C and placing such a huge batch is bound to be problematic However here the rosy picture in this report makes me think what is the missing link. We all understand the situation of Inside IIM since it is the Bschools decision to declare the placement data, however I am really not agreeing with the supersweet picture painted above. It would have been lot better had they contacted IIMI students

13 Dec 2012, 12.01 AM

+Read Replies (4)

IIM student

@rahul - IIM Indore has a very stringent mechanism in place. Any report/news that goes out to the media is duly verified by the Director. i believe you are not an IIM student because inside an IIM, the student&#039;s expectations are very high and some people will always complain (even with offers of Goldman, Deutsche etc) while the others will be realistic. Now that the season has ended you can talk to any of your friends inside the campus to verify if any of the above firms did not roll out any offer.

13 Dec 2012, 01.45 AM |

Subrmanian N

Too much rosy, I would say ... many of my friends at IIM I reports something else and they also advised me not to join IIM I for the same, but this report says something else... I am confused now. Don&#039;t know what to believe actually

13 Dec 2012, 01.24 PM |

Neutral_Junta

If you are confident of cracking ABC then you should definitely try for ABC or at-most L. Among IIM&#039;s these are much better than the rest. But please remember that at ABCL, if you are not a topper with very good profile you might end up with a worse job than that you would have got at I. Everyone thinks that he/she will be comfortably among the top 50% in IIM&#039;s. However its a lot difficult at ABCL than at I/K or any of the new IIM&#039;s. Try researching on the kind of jobs got by the last 150/100 students even at IIMABCL and you will understand that the truth.

13 Dec 2012, 02.11 PM |

IIM student

You can have a look at the official report released on the site <a href="http://www.iimidr.ac.in/iimi/media/pdf/placements/Summer%20report_2012-14.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://www.iimidr.ac.in/iimi/media/pdf/placements...</a> If you are comfortable with the companies mentioned there is no reason for you not to join. Different people have different views and expectations.

13 Dec 2012, 02.43 PM |

Guest

IIMC ka report kab aayega?

13 Dec 2012, 12.21 AM

Official Report

here is the official report from IIM Indore <a href="http://www.iimidr.ac.in/iimi/media/pdf/placements/Summer%20report_2012-14.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://www.iimidr.ac.in/iimi/media/pdf/placements...</a>

13 Dec 2012, 12.57 AM

@InsideIIM

Team InsideIIM is acutely aware about the &#039;Let&#039;s praise our own institute&#039; contest going on right now. Please refrain from continuing this further. If you have valid facts and data which you want to put forward you are welcome. But random bragging makes the thread useless and makes the students of a premier institution look even worse.

13 Dec 2012, 05.23 PM

Finance

Only 17% of the batch got profiles in finance ? thats too less ....Infact lowest amongst all Top 10 B schools !

13 Dec 2012, 08.56 PM

+Read Replies (1)

IIM student

atleast the campus ethical enough to disclose the break-up unlike some other schools who are combining fin and marketing and quoting the joint figure finance has taken a hit in terms of number of offers no doubt but there is great diversity in profiles being offered. and FYI - the finance placements are comparable to other B Schools in the same league, maybe even better in terms of number of options available

13 Dec 2012, 09.48 PM |

Ajinkya

Average stipend of Rs. 67000 for IIMI and Rs. 40000 for IIMK. Now that&#039;s something interesting. I do not know whether it&#039;s a type, but the word &quot;p.m.&quot; i.e. per month is missing in the I report. Team InsideIIM, can we safely assume that the stipend of I is for two months ?

15 Dec 2012, 03.11 PM

+Read Replies (10)

PMo

of course its for 2 months dude !! an avg stipend of 67k per month would put it in the same league as IIM L,XL, FMS .. wch it is ...well not :P

16 Dec 2012, 02.32 AM |

IIM student

@PMo - get ur facts straight atleast. None of the above mentioned colleges have avg stipend at or around 67k. pm. which you would have known had you been studying in any one of them. I know for sure coz 4 people from my family are currently studying there. And wen u compare avg stipend use a bit of common sense and look at similar batch sizes or the top similar number of students in a college with a bigger batch size.

16 Dec 2012, 06.28 PM |

PMo

I dnt get this nonsense argument of &quot;larger batch size&quot; put forth by IIM indore and kozhikode everytime , what about the last 200 students , arent they important to the college ? didnt they pay fees ? didnt they crack CAT ? then why why do you alwayz give reason of &quot;larger batch size&quot; while comparing average package ? Also why dnt u realise that smaller batch sizes are actually a strength fr colleges like FMS ,XLRI ,JBIMS compared to IIM I,K and the probability of every student getting a decent job in higher in this institutes then in IIM I,K due to smaller batch sizes . Also why arent IIM A,B,C,L complaining about the larger batch sizes ?

17 Dec 2012, 01.13 PM |

Public

@PMo - i guess you arent a part of any of the above mentioned colleges - so stop reacting. Most of the colleges have stopped giving stipend numbers and also the finals average packages at the above mentioned colleges have taken a hit due to the increased batch sizes. Also, due to reservations there is a lot of difference in the profiles and CAT %ile of top 250-300 students at the large IIMs other institutes where reservations are not there. And hence when you compare offers you should compare only the ones where entry is open and not reserved across colleges. And hence the comparison of the top 250 at different IIMs with the batches of private smaller colleges with no reservations

17 Dec 2012, 01.58 PM |

PMo

I guess you are not even a part of any B school as yet , its nt necessary that in the bottom 250 all reserved candidates are there, though reserved candidates have lower CAT % , some of them have very good profiles and the recruiters dnt come to know about their lower CAT percentiles . So it often happens that many general candidates end up in bottom 250 , so i am just saying that stating just the average of top 250 might be misleading to aspirants as they never know in which part of the pyramid they will be in after joining the B school , hence they need to know the complete picture.

17 Dec 2012, 02.29 PM |

IIM I Student

u r 100% correct. In fact these campuses use the misleading term &#039;top 250&#039;. These people are not the top 250 in terms of the acads or in terms of cat percentile or in terms of profile. It is the average of &#039;TOP 250 STIPENDS&#039; offered.

17 Dec 2012, 07.22 PM |

Rhetoric

But in this report, they have given the average stipend for total batch too. In fact, they have been so transparent that they have given the details of top 50 , top 250 etc too. For you it may not be of any use. But for any aspirant, it gives better picture, no. Ultimately in case of placement reports, every bit of information given in the public is of huge help for aspirants!

17 Dec 2012, 10.42 PM |

PMo

My point is , there is no point in coming out with fancy top 50&#039;s and top 250&#039;s because average is only one and any other figure given is nothing bt a trick to divert attention from the lower average .

18 Dec 2012, 01.06 AM |

Public

@PMo - I m a current student at one of the top IIMs in the country.

18 Dec 2012, 04.56 PM |

Rhetoric

Nope 1) Average is not only one. Depending upon sample size, their can be multiple averages. 2) You are free to interpret the way you want. May be, there will be some 500 guys from a so called better management institute, who want IIM Indore to show only the lower stipend because of any fear or whatever. But most of the remaining audience will prefer a detailed info about figures than giving just one number!

19 Dec 2012, 01.17 AM |

IIMI PGP student

The official placement process has ended. Only the students who opted out during the process are unplaced. But then that is their own (un)doing. If one is not confident of cracking an internship on his own, doesn&#039;t make a lot of sense to sign out, does it? All students who were a part of the process till the end have landed an internship. I don&#039;t know the exact no. of students who opted out.

16 Dec 2012, 06.02 PM

Sceptical

I know for a fact that there are many many students who are unplaced! I REPEAT UNPLACED in IIM I! pls investigate or talk to students! I know my friends who are not plaed YET! and I mean MANY OF THEM! This report is just a PR stunt! Dissapointing to see Inside IIM endorsing it! Really disapointed!

14 Dec 2012, 10.50 PM

an IIM student

avg salary of 67k... its just impossible.. the say 100 new companie brought on campus... how can one believe that all these 100 companies are top notch companies?? most of them are startups.. and they pay a startup stipend.. i.e 15-20k.. and complete batch placed... all this is a mirage.. I have many frnds who are not yet placed.. officially they opted out.. but why?? coz they did not had any option.. there has to be some standard of reporting placements.. I cant believe how an IIM is using such cheap tricks to improve its reputation..

18 Dec 2012, 06.32 PM

+Read Replies (3)

Wat_Nonsense

Don&#039;t talk nonsense. Even 15-20K p.m. figure claimed by you leads to 30, 40 K for 2 months. So that can easily be among lower range for average to be 67 K. So 67K is perfectly believable. Again many friends ? How many ? How ambiguous? No option to them but to opt out? This is too much. Please re-frame the questions. Don&#039;t speak for the sake of it.

19 Dec 2012, 01.25 AM |

Insider

Its not that simple as it seems is it ? wat about the last 50 who were placed with zero stipend ? Imagine the impact they will have on the average .

20 Dec 2012, 01.48 AM |

IIM Indore student

how do you know that 50 were placed without any stipend? The number of people who went for zero stipend was v v v less than that. And all of those opted to go for zero stipend as the firms they got placed were some of the biggest brand names mentioned in the report above and the profiles offered were awesome. It makes a lot of sense to choose a good profile over a good stipend and this view is shared by the whole B School community including the team at insideIIM

22 Dec 2012, 11.08 AM |

iim

<a href="https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=542268989136310&amp;set=a.468353603194516.115414.462307553799121&amp;type=1&amp;theater" rel="nofollow">https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=542268989...</a>

19 Dec 2012, 11.43 PM

Brendan

My own rankings system - Ranked 1 - IIM A, IIMB, IIM C &amp; to some extent IIM L Ranked 2 - JBIMS, XLRI J, SP Jain &amp; FMS D Ranked 3 - IIM I &amp; IIM K Ranked 4 - NMIMS, MDI G &amp; IIFT Ranked 5 - IMT G, SIBM P, XIM B, Nitie &amp; SJSOM

29 Dec 2012, 01.49 PM

+Read Replies (1)

hehehe

My own rankings system - Ranked 0 - IIPM Ranked 1 - IIM A, IIMB, IIM C ,IIM L to some extent IIM I &amp; IIM K Ranked 2 - , XLRI J, SP Jain &amp; FMS D Ranked 3 - JBIMS, MDI G &amp; IIFT Ranked 4 - NMIMS, Ranked 5 - IMT G, SIBM P, XIM B, Nitie &amp; SJSOM

31 Dec 2012, 04.22 PM |

anon

My ranking of Bschools __Ranked 1 - IIM A, IIMC, IIMB, IIM L __Ranked 2 - ISB H, JBIMS, XLRI J &amp; FMS D __Ranked 3 -SP Jain, IIM I, IIM K, IIFT __Ranked 4 - NMIMS, MDI G &amp; IMT G, SIBM P, XIM B, Nitie &amp; SJSOM __XL/FMS are no longer contenders for fifth rank as ISB has overatken them to claim fifth spot. Kudos ISB. _

31 Dec 2012, 11.36 PM

Gigli

Tough crowd! Good to see decent number of brands. Not easy for an IIM that&#039;s not in the top 3

14 Jan 2013, 07.56 PM

IIM I student

Wait for finals report. The list will include - BCG, Deutsche Bank - Front End Ibanking, Bank of America Merrill Lynch, Deloitte S&amp;O, Microsoft, TAS, HUL, P&amp;G Sales and many more

14 Jan 2013, 08.33 PM

Aspirant Help

This is unfair reporting. Almost 50+ students have got unpaid internship. If the college does not go for standard auditing,IPRS its the responsibility of insideiim to interact with either student pool of college to get the real scene.

24 Jan 2013, 09.28 AM

+Read Replies (1)

IIM I Student

Dear Aspirant. Kindly verify your facts. No of students going for zero stipend intern is very very less than wat u claim. Kindly read the comments above to know the truth. Also, a lot of people prefer a good profile over a good stipend and a college should ensure that all such options are available to the students

13 Feb 2013, 02.54 PM |

Mini Mock Test

Final 2 Days to CAT 2024 Test-44

Participants: 229

Final 3 Days to CAT 2024 Test-43

Participants: 249
College Comparison Tool - Quiz Ad

Final 4 Days to CAT 2024 Test-42

Participants: 326

Final 5 Days to CAT 2024 Test-41

Participants: 352

Final 6 Days to CAT 2024 Test-40

Participants: 339

Final 7 Days to CAT 2024 Test-39

Participants: 335

Final 8 Days to CAT 2024 Test-38

Participants: 311

Final 9 Days to CAT 2024 Test-37

Participants: 324

Final 10 Days to CAT 2024 Test-36

Participants: 285

Final 11 Days to CAT 2024 Test-35

Participants: 475

Final 12 Days to CAT 2024 Test-34

Participants: 330

Final 13 Days to CAT 2024 Test-33

Participants: 293

Final 14 Days to CAT 2024 Test-32

Participants: 275

Final 15 Days to CAT 2024 Test-31

Participants: 357

Final 16 Days to CAT 2024 Test-30

Participants: 289

Final 17 Days to CAT 2024 Test-29

Participants: 310

Final 18 Days to CAT 2024 Test-28

Participants: 341

Final 19 Days to CAT 2024 Test-26

Participants: 338

Final 20 Days to CAT 2024 Test-26

Participants: 306

Final 21 Days to CAT 2024 Test-25

Participants: 249

Final 22 Days to CAT 2024 Test-24

Participants: 266

Final 23 Days to CAT 2024 Test-23

Participants: 178

Final 24 Days to CAT 2024 Test-22

Participants: 225

Final 25 Days to CAT 2024 Test-21

Participants: 223

Final 26 Days to CAT 2024 Test-20

Participants: 276

Final 27 Days to CAT 2024 Test-19

Participants: 230

Final 28 Days to CAT 2024 Test-18

Participants: 233

Final 29 Days to CAT 2024 Test-17

Participants: 245

Final 30 Days to CAT 2024 Test-16

Participants: 276

Final 31 Days to CAT 2024 Test-15

Participants: 271

Take Free Test Here

Comments
 

Rohit

Good show. Many new names. Good to see some one give stipend distribution. Very good to see honesty in international offers figure. 12 is realistic. IIM K with 20 is definitely inflated. But I notice that slowdown has hit IIM I a little. I don&#039;t see BCG, Bank Of America Merrill Lynch, Accenture Management Consulting, J&amp;J Consumer. They all recruited last year. In fact regular recruiter Standard Chartered Bank is also missing. TAS was always going to be a problem after what happened last year.

11 Dec 2012, 08.02 PM

+Read Replies (15)

IIM I Student

Well. You will see both BCG and Bank of America Merrill Lynch in the finals report in a couple of months from now. Don&#039;t really want to comment on the other misses.

11 Dec 2012, 08.10 PM |

FYI

Firms like BCG, McKinsey have hired in big numbers from the top campuses this year. BCG picked up 14 interns from IIMA, 12 each from IIMB and IIMC. Around 7 from IIML. A total of 45 interns from the top 4 IIMs. That is a huge number. Mckinsey again picked up 10 from IIMA, 11 from IIMB, 8 from IIMC, 6 from IIML i.e. around 35 interns from the top IIMs. Accenture picked up atleast 10 each from ABCL., a total of atleast 40 across the top 4 campuses. ATKearney infact added IIML to their campus list. All in all, big consulting firms are hiring big time. They are not really affected by the slowing economy. But they have cut on campuses and recruited in more numbers from their favourite campuses. It seems that they want to associate themselves only with the big and established brands.

12 Dec 2012, 06.03 PM |

abc

u forgot to mention xlri..BCG came there as well.

12 Dec 2012, 07.02 PM |

Vipul L

Nice try to improve PR of the college....I heard one of my Indore friend saying that there was literally no companies for over 200+ students. I was surprised after giving a sly look on this report. It looks as if they have beaten all the records. I am amazed on their proficiency to hide the real truth. Can you also clarify on the duration for summer placements this time?

12 Dec 2012, 07.50 PM |

Obvious

These firms take some time in convincing. You forget that IIM I is only 15 yrs old while other campuses are much older. Also you must consider that BCG is a regular recruiter at IIM I for finals and it should probably turn up for next summers or the one after that AMC turned up for last yrs summers at IIM I so once they have good numbers they will probably come back. With BCG coming, its only a matter of time before the other consults also start coming

13 Dec 2012, 01.35 AM |

Use Logic

@vipul - do you think the time required for summers is a good criteria for gauging the quality of placements? Dude - do you think that will 180+ companies giving offers they would have placed only 250?? Seriously? Ask any person in a B-School 180 companies are enough for 420-30 offers. you will find similar no of companies giving offers on other IIMs with similar batch sizes

13 Dec 2012, 01.40 AM |

Prabhu

Just to clarify....AT Kearney has not added IIML to the list. It has always been one of the 5 schools of choice as can be seen here - <a href="http://www.atkearney.com/careers/apply/india" rel="nofollow">http://www.atkearney.com/careers/apply/india</a>. And I have known for a fact that they recruited from there for the 2008 batch....

13 Dec 2012, 10.31 AM |

FYI

It does not recruit from IIML on a regular basis. It visits ABC every placement process. Nonetheless, thanks for the information.

13 Dec 2012, 12.48 PM |

question

No the point can you prove &quot;180 companies&quot; &quot;actually recruited&quot; from IIM I .......? #LogicFlawed

13 Dec 2012, 08.49 PM |

IIM student

its clearly written in the last graph that 181 companies gave offers. its also mentioned in their official release quoted on their site. and if u dnt believe that - dunno wat u will believe. Its a pity actually. Some people cant resist venting out their frustration on public forums

13 Dec 2012, 09.51 PM |

DontBelieveBS

well i also dont belive on this report too [ may it be OFFICIAL TOO ] .

14 Dec 2012, 05.05 AM |

question

No , i completely trust insideIIM.com , they are doing a great job, but they have there limitations too , there is no way in which they can verify whether 180 companies actually recruited , they simply print the report which is given to them by the placecom and there is no venting out of frustration , its just about finding out the truth so that aspirants don&#039;t get fooled by the rosy picture painted by students of premeir B schools and later regret their decision , which btw many people in IIM I are doing right nw .

14 Dec 2012, 08.38 PM |

Kudos_IIM I

Right now, most of the ppl at IIM I are celebrating their stellar summers (probably next to just 4-5 B Schools in the country). This coming from an IIM I student, I hope you won&#039;t believe this too. :P

14 Dec 2012, 09.13 PM |

LOL

LOL good 1!! next to just 4-5 B schools in the country :P LOL dude do you think students at countries top B schools believe those rankings u guys pay for ? :P we hav gt our brains and a common sense tooo :P

16 Dec 2012, 02.28 AM |

Logic

@LOL - u have some brains? wat a surprise coz it doesnt seem from your comments :P Anyways no IIM pays for his/her rankings as they are govt institutes

16 Dec 2012, 06.21 PM |

Vikas

Kudos to the placement committee for doing a great job till the end. 100 plus new companies is no joke. Also cheers for once again maintaining an ethical stand in reporting all figures and company names.

11 Dec 2012, 08.20 PM

finance

Over 40% in sales and marketing , says it all , its been a bad year for finance in all B schools with exception of IIM L , hope it improves till next year or many may reluctantly switch to marketing.

11 Dec 2012, 08.42 PM

question

Why are number of students signing out and Total no. of offers not disclosed ?? how does one come to know whether how many students actually got internship ?

11 Dec 2012, 08.46 PM

+Read Replies (1)

@InsideIIM

That is a problem. But there is no way we can get that information or even verify when someone does actually state a figure. IIM I, FMS and IIM K decided not to report that statistic. Even the ones who have reported, we can&#039;t realistically verify it. The best way to find this out is to speak to a student from the campus.

11 Dec 2012, 08.57 PM |

Flaneur

Kudos to the placement committee !! 100 new companies takes huge effort .

11 Dec 2012, 11.41 PM

@InsideIIM

That statement has no basis. Please exercise caution before writing such comments. Any such comparisons without data and basis will be deleted.

12 Dec 2012, 12.25 AM

Ritesh

Excellent job indeed.. Hope it continues in the finals as well

12 Dec 2012, 12.27 AM

Sceptic

Just way too much goody goody congratulations going on here. Let&#039;s not forget a lot of recruiters have not returned to campus this year for Summers. Someone mentioned it earlier. Whether it was bad strategy on Placement Committee&#039;s part or bad luck or whatever the truth is that the placements could have been better. No doubt people have worked hard to get the placements done but I find the congratulations here over the top. Be more realistic guys.

12 Dec 2012, 12.42 AM

RCH89

@ The Glaring Truth ... Lol ... That&#039;s the funniest comment I have come across in the recent times

12 Dec 2012, 02.34 AM

Subbu

Rosy picture....heard summers were pretty bad this time around at IIM I...spread over months while other IIMs finished it off in weeks

12 Dec 2012, 08.38 AM

+Read Replies (1)

Neutral_Junta

Bad as compared to ? Last year ? IIM ABCL ? I dont think its fair to compare I with ABCL which are older colleges and which have all the big consulting and fin firms recruiting regularly. However I can say good if the performance has been better than last summers. Many new companies came but many companies didn&#039;t as seen from last year&#039;s report. However looking at the reports last year and this year, the numbers seem better this year.

13 Dec 2012, 01.11 AM |

Rahul Kar

I am confused. Two of my friends study in the IIMI campus and they were telling me how bad the situation inside the campus is and common sense also says That Indore is not IIM C and placing such a huge batch is bound to be problematic However here the rosy picture in this report makes me think what is the missing link. We all understand the situation of Inside IIM since it is the Bschools decision to declare the placement data, however I am really not agreeing with the supersweet picture painted above. It would have been lot better had they contacted IIMI students

13 Dec 2012, 12.01 AM

+Read Replies (4)

IIM student

@rahul - IIM Indore has a very stringent mechanism in place. Any report/news that goes out to the media is duly verified by the Director. i believe you are not an IIM student because inside an IIM, the student&#039;s expectations are very high and some people will always complain (even with offers of Goldman, Deutsche etc) while the others will be realistic. Now that the season has ended you can talk to any of your friends inside the campus to verify if any of the above firms did not roll out any offer.

13 Dec 2012, 01.45 AM |

Subrmanian N

Too much rosy, I would say ... many of my friends at IIM I reports something else and they also advised me not to join IIM I for the same, but this report says something else... I am confused now. Don&#039;t know what to believe actually

13 Dec 2012, 01.24 PM |

Neutral_Junta

If you are confident of cracking ABC then you should definitely try for ABC or at-most L. Among IIM&#039;s these are much better than the rest. But please remember that at ABCL, if you are not a topper with very good profile you might end up with a worse job than that you would have got at I. Everyone thinks that he/she will be comfortably among the top 50% in IIM&#039;s. However its a lot difficult at ABCL than at I/K or any of the new IIM&#039;s. Try researching on the kind of jobs got by the last 150/100 students even at IIMABCL and you will understand that the truth.

13 Dec 2012, 02.11 PM |

IIM student

You can have a look at the official report released on the site <a href="http://www.iimidr.ac.in/iimi/media/pdf/placements/Summer%20report_2012-14.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://www.iimidr.ac.in/iimi/media/pdf/placements...</a> If you are comfortable with the companies mentioned there is no reason for you not to join. Different people have different views and expectations.

13 Dec 2012, 02.43 PM |

Guest

IIMC ka report kab aayega?

13 Dec 2012, 12.21 AM

Official Report

here is the official report from IIM Indore <a href="http://www.iimidr.ac.in/iimi/media/pdf/placements/Summer%20report_2012-14.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://www.iimidr.ac.in/iimi/media/pdf/placements...</a>

13 Dec 2012, 12.57 AM

@InsideIIM

Team InsideIIM is acutely aware about the &#039;Let&#039;s praise our own institute&#039; contest going on right now. Please refrain from continuing this further. If you have valid facts and data which you want to put forward you are welcome. But random bragging makes the thread useless and makes the students of a premier institution look even worse.

13 Dec 2012, 05.23 PM

Finance

Only 17% of the batch got profiles in finance ? thats too less ....Infact lowest amongst all Top 10 B schools !

13 Dec 2012, 08.56 PM

+Read Replies (1)

IIM student

atleast the campus ethical enough to disclose the break-up unlike some other schools who are combining fin and marketing and quoting the joint figure finance has taken a hit in terms of number of offers no doubt but there is great diversity in profiles being offered. and FYI - the finance placements are comparable to other B Schools in the same league, maybe even better in terms of number of options available

13 Dec 2012, 09.48 PM |

Ajinkya

Average stipend of Rs. 67000 for IIMI and Rs. 40000 for IIMK. Now that&#039;s something interesting. I do not know whether it&#039;s a type, but the word &quot;p.m.&quot; i.e. per month is missing in the I report. Team InsideIIM, can we safely assume that the stipend of I is for two months ?

15 Dec 2012, 03.11 PM

+Read Replies (10)

PMo

of course its for 2 months dude !! an avg stipend of 67k per month would put it in the same league as IIM L,XL, FMS .. wch it is ...well not :P

16 Dec 2012, 02.32 AM |

IIM student

@PMo - get ur facts straight atleast. None of the above mentioned colleges have avg stipend at or around 67k. pm. which you would have known had you been studying in any one of them. I know for sure coz 4 people from my family are currently studying there. And wen u compare avg stipend use a bit of common sense and look at similar batch sizes or the top similar number of students in a college with a bigger batch size.

16 Dec 2012, 06.28 PM |

PMo

I dnt get this nonsense argument of &quot;larger batch size&quot; put forth by IIM indore and kozhikode everytime , what about the last 200 students , arent they important to the college ? didnt they pay fees ? didnt they crack CAT ? then why why do you alwayz give reason of &quot;larger batch size&quot; while comparing average package ? Also why dnt u realise that smaller batch sizes are actually a strength fr colleges like FMS ,XLRI ,JBIMS compared to IIM I,K and the probability of every student getting a decent job in higher in this institutes then in IIM I,K due to smaller batch sizes . Also why arent IIM A,B,C,L complaining about the larger batch sizes ?

17 Dec 2012, 01.13 PM |

Public

@PMo - i guess you arent a part of any of the above mentioned colleges - so stop reacting. Most of the colleges have stopped giving stipend numbers and also the finals average packages at the above mentioned colleges have taken a hit due to the increased batch sizes. Also, due to reservations there is a lot of difference in the profiles and CAT %ile of top 250-300 students at the large IIMs other institutes where reservations are not there. And hence when you compare offers you should compare only the ones where entry is open and not reserved across colleges. And hence the comparison of the top 250 at different IIMs with the batches of private smaller colleges with no reservations

17 Dec 2012, 01.58 PM |

PMo

I guess you are not even a part of any B school as yet , its nt necessary that in the bottom 250 all reserved candidates are there, though reserved candidates have lower CAT % , some of them have very good profiles and the recruiters dnt come to know about their lower CAT percentiles . So it often happens that many general candidates end up in bottom 250 , so i am just saying that stating just the average of top 250 might be misleading to aspirants as they never know in which part of the pyramid they will be in after joining the B school , hence they need to know the complete picture.

17 Dec 2012, 02.29 PM |

IIM I Student

u r 100% correct. In fact these campuses use the misleading term &#039;top 250&#039;. These people are not the top 250 in terms of the acads or in terms of cat percentile or in terms of profile. It is the average of &#039;TOP 250 STIPENDS&#039; offered.

17 Dec 2012, 07.22 PM |

Rhetoric

But in this report, they have given the average stipend for total batch too. In fact, they have been so transparent that they have given the details of top 50 , top 250 etc too. For you it may not be of any use. But for any aspirant, it gives better picture, no. Ultimately in case of placement reports, every bit of information given in the public is of huge help for aspirants!

17 Dec 2012, 10.42 PM |

PMo

My point is , there is no point in coming out with fancy top 50&#039;s and top 250&#039;s because average is only one and any other figure given is nothing bt a trick to divert attention from the lower average .

18 Dec 2012, 01.06 AM |

Public

@PMo - I m a current student at one of the top IIMs in the country.

18 Dec 2012, 04.56 PM |

Rhetoric

Nope 1) Average is not only one. Depending upon sample size, their can be multiple averages. 2) You are free to interpret the way you want. May be, there will be some 500 guys from a so called better management institute, who want IIM Indore to show only the lower stipend because of any fear or whatever. But most of the remaining audience will prefer a detailed info about figures than giving just one number!

19 Dec 2012, 01.17 AM |

IIMI PGP student

The official placement process has ended. Only the students who opted out during the process are unplaced. But then that is their own (un)doing. If one is not confident of cracking an internship on his own, doesn&#039;t make a lot of sense to sign out, does it? All students who were a part of the process till the end have landed an internship. I don&#039;t know the exact no. of students who opted out.

16 Dec 2012, 06.02 PM

Sceptical

I know for a fact that there are many many students who are unplaced! I REPEAT UNPLACED in IIM I! pls investigate or talk to students! I know my friends who are not plaed YET! and I mean MANY OF THEM! This report is just a PR stunt! Dissapointing to see Inside IIM endorsing it! Really disapointed!

14 Dec 2012, 10.50 PM

an IIM student

avg salary of 67k... its just impossible.. the say 100 new companie brought on campus... how can one believe that all these 100 companies are top notch companies?? most of them are startups.. and they pay a startup stipend.. i.e 15-20k.. and complete batch placed... all this is a mirage.. I have many frnds who are not yet placed.. officially they opted out.. but why?? coz they did not had any option.. there has to be some standard of reporting placements.. I cant believe how an IIM is using such cheap tricks to improve its reputation..

18 Dec 2012, 06.32 PM

+Read Replies (3)

Wat_Nonsense

Don&#039;t talk nonsense. Even 15-20K p.m. figure claimed by you leads to 30, 40 K for 2 months. So that can easily be among lower range for average to be 67 K. So 67K is perfectly believable. Again many friends ? How many ? How ambiguous? No option to them but to opt out? This is too much. Please re-frame the questions. Don&#039;t speak for the sake of it.

19 Dec 2012, 01.25 AM |

Insider

Its not that simple as it seems is it ? wat about the last 50 who were placed with zero stipend ? Imagine the impact they will have on the average .

20 Dec 2012, 01.48 AM |

IIM Indore student

how do you know that 50 were placed without any stipend? The number of people who went for zero stipend was v v v less than that. And all of those opted to go for zero stipend as the firms they got placed were some of the biggest brand names mentioned in the report above and the profiles offered were awesome. It makes a lot of sense to choose a good profile over a good stipend and this view is shared by the whole B School community including the team at insideIIM

22 Dec 2012, 11.08 AM |

iim

<a href="https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=542268989136310&amp;set=a.468353603194516.115414.462307553799121&amp;type=1&amp;theater" rel="nofollow">https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=542268989...</a>

19 Dec 2012, 11.43 PM

Brendan

My own rankings system - Ranked 1 - IIM A, IIMB, IIM C &amp; to some extent IIM L Ranked 2 - JBIMS, XLRI J, SP Jain &amp; FMS D Ranked 3 - IIM I &amp; IIM K Ranked 4 - NMIMS, MDI G &amp; IIFT Ranked 5 - IMT G, SIBM P, XIM B, Nitie &amp; SJSOM

29 Dec 2012, 01.49 PM

+Read Replies (1)

hehehe

My own rankings system - Ranked 0 - IIPM Ranked 1 - IIM A, IIMB, IIM C ,IIM L to some extent IIM I &amp; IIM K Ranked 2 - , XLRI J, SP Jain &amp; FMS D Ranked 3 - JBIMS, MDI G &amp; IIFT Ranked 4 - NMIMS, Ranked 5 - IMT G, SIBM P, XIM B, Nitie &amp; SJSOM

31 Dec 2012, 04.22 PM |

anon

My ranking of Bschools __Ranked 1 - IIM A, IIMC, IIMB, IIM L __Ranked 2 - ISB H, JBIMS, XLRI J &amp; FMS D __Ranked 3 -SP Jain, IIM I, IIM K, IIFT __Ranked 4 - NMIMS, MDI G &amp; IMT G, SIBM P, XIM B, Nitie &amp; SJSOM __XL/FMS are no longer contenders for fifth rank as ISB has overatken them to claim fifth spot. Kudos ISB. _

31 Dec 2012, 11.36 PM

Gigli

Tough crowd! Good to see decent number of brands. Not easy for an IIM that&#039;s not in the top 3

14 Jan 2013, 07.56 PM

IIM I student

Wait for finals report. The list will include - BCG, Deutsche Bank - Front End Ibanking, Bank of America Merrill Lynch, Deloitte S&amp;O, Microsoft, TAS, HUL, P&amp;G Sales and many more

14 Jan 2013, 08.33 PM

Aspirant Help

This is unfair reporting. Almost 50+ students have got unpaid internship. If the college does not go for standard auditing,IPRS its the responsibility of insideiim to interact with either student pool of college to get the real scene.

24 Jan 2013, 09.28 AM

+Read Replies (1)

IIM I Student

Dear Aspirant. Kindly verify your facts. No of students going for zero stipend intern is very very less than wat u claim. Kindly read the comments above to know the truth. Also, a lot of people prefer a good profile over a good stipend and a college should ensure that all such options are available to the students

13 Feb 2013, 02.54 PM |